 |
| Schumer |
“They have dressed the wound of my people with very little care, saying, ‘Peace, peace,’ when there is no peace [at all]” -- Jeremiah 6:14, from a Hebrew translation.
According to an AP report reprinted with some
excisions in the Hartford Courant on March 15, 2024, “Senate Majority Leader
Chuck Schumer on Thursday called on Israel to hold new elections, saying he
believes Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has ‘lost his way’ and is an
obstacle to peace in the region amid a growing humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
“Schumer, the first Jewish majority leader in the Senate and
the highest-ranking Jewish official in the U.S., strongly criticized Netanyahu
in a 40-minute speech Thursday morning on the Senate floor. Schumer said the
prime minister has put himself in a coalition of far-right extremists and as a
result, he has been too willing to tolerate the civilian toll in Gaza, which is
pushing support for Israel worldwide to historic lows.
“’Israel cannot survive if it becomes a pariah,’ Schumer
said.”
Among its enemies, of course, Israel has been a pariah state
ever since its inception in the modern period.
The AP report notes that “Schumer has so far positioned
himself as a strong ally of the Israeli government, visiting the country just
days after the brutal Oct. 7 attack by Hamas and giving a lengthy speech on the
Senate floor in December decrying ‘brazen and widespread anti-Semitism the
likes of which we haven’t seen in generations in this country, if ever.’
“But he said on the Senate floor Thursday that the ‘Israeli
people are being stifled right now by a governing vision that is stuck in the
past.’
“Schumer says Netanyahu, who has long opposed Palestinian
statehood, is one of several obstacles in the way of the two-state solution
pushed by the United States. Netanyahu ‘has lost his way by allowing his
political survival to take precedence over the best interests of Israel,’
Schumer said.”
The full text of Schumer’s remarks calling for new elections
in Israel that will lead to a replacement of Netanyahu as Prime Minister of
Israel, Schumer hopes, was printed in full by the Times of Israel on March 15, 2024.
The opening of Schumer’s remarks is significant, if embarrassingly
self-important, because it invests Schumer with an air of authority as “a
guardian of the people of Israel.”
Addressing his colleagues in the U.S. Senate and, beyond
them “friends” of Israel, Schumer rose “to speak today about what I believe can
— and should — be the path forward to secure mutual peace and lasting
prosperity for Israelis and Palestinians.”
Schumer’s path to peace is remarkably well worn. Years ago
when Joe Biden was Vice President during the administration of President Barack
Obama, the president, hoping to derail the re-election of Netanyahu, sent his
campaign professionals into Israel to aid Netanyahu’s opponent. Friends of
Israel here in the United States concluded that Obama wished to shove Netanyahu
from the political stage because he did not want loose tongues to jeopardize
clandestine U.S. negotiations with Iran, now the principal deep-pocket
supporter of anti-Israeli terrorist groups in the Middle East. Obama’s Iranian
inducements included planeloads of cash delivered to Iran – without the
approval of the U.S. Congress – under cover of darkness. Few Democrats at the
time dared call it bribery.
“I speak for myself,” Schumer declaimed, “but I also speak
for so many mainstream Jewish Americans — a silent majority — whose nuanced
views on the matter have never been well represented in this country’s
discussions about the war in Gaza.”
“My last name is Schumer, which derives from the Hebrew word
Shomer, or ‘guardian.’ Of course, my first responsibility is to America and New
York. But as the first Jewish Majority Leader of the United States Senate, and
the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in America ever, I also feel very
keenly my responsibility as Shomer Yisroel — a guardian of the People of
Israel.”
And the guardianship of Israel can best be assured, Schumer
insisted, by replacing Netanyahu as a Prime Minister of Israel at war with
Hamas, Hezbollah, the Houthis and Iran, a nation pledged to destroy Israel that
has directed and financed the present expanded war on Israel.
It remains to be seen whether Schumer – like Senator
Blumenthal of Connecticut, also Jewish and presumptively a friend of Israel –
is a more faithful guardian of Israel than Netanyahu.
There can be no doubt that Schumer and Blumenthal are faithful
political water carriers for President Joe Biden, whose understanding of the
history of Israel since the Israeli state was formed in 1948 is lacking in
detail and less precise than that of Netanyahu and the Israeli military.
Voices within the Democrat Party are hardly speaking in
unison. Socialist Vermont U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders, also Jewish, wishes to
return Israel to its status quo ante
before the assault on Israel on October 7, 2023 convinced some in the United
States that Iran’s vision of a Middle East without the state of Israel has been
put on a progressive path. Any successful military opposition to Iran and its
terrorist helpmates might easily be portrayed by accomplished political
rhetoricians – Sanders is one of these -- as needlessly violent and a blow to a
“two state solution” that, largely because of Iranian opposition, has never and
will never succeed. Sanders entered the U.S. Senate in2006, Schumer in 1999
but, in the matter of chutzpah, Sanders is by far the senior politician.
To his credit, Schumer, in his unedited remarks, has plainly said
that Hamas cannot be one of the states in any two-state solution, and he does
manage properly to affix blame for the undoubted failure of a two-state
solution squarely on Iran, the terrorists and, not mentioned, American leftist politicians
seemingly unfamiliar with the last three decades of Middle East turmoil. It
should be noted, however, that Schumer and Blumenthal have yet to launch any
serious objection to Sander’s notion that the United States must immediately halt
all aid to Israel until such time as prominent Israelis warmly embrace the
failed two-state solution and immediately put a stop to their aggressive
military maneuvers.
No prominent American politician on the right has yet
proposed that Israel should impose on Gaza a decades-long protectorate that
will allow Gazans to develop organically in the absence of terrorist tunnels
built under hospitals by Hamas terrorists and the pressure brought to bear upon
them by its governing authority in league, as we all know, with Iran, whose
leaders have yet to suffer any serious disappointments.
Repeating the errors of the Obama administration, Biden has
removed oil distribution sanctions imposed on Iran – far more lucrative than
plane loads of cash – in hopes that the leaders of Iran, declared enemies of
both Israel and the United States, will be brought to their knees by goodwill
gestures.
Biden is not a creative president, and the fog of war in the
Middle East is far less foggy than the fog of an American election campaign. The
“path forward” to a two-state solution, pursued unsuccessfully for decades by
lovers of peace and prosperity in the United States, may have been a spectacular
failure for all but Iran and the enemies of peace and prosperity in Gaza, but
hope springs eternal, despite the prophetic warnings of Jeremiah, a prophet well
acquainted with the deceptive actions of those who offer superficial solutions
and false assurances, especially in the face of significant challenges.
Comments