Skip to main content

Why There Is No Polarization in Connecticut

Lamont and His General Assembly

Everybody talks about the weather, but nobody ever does anything about it, said either Mark Twain or, more likely, Hartford Courant editor Charles Dudley Warner, a close friend of Twain’s.

The same may be said of political polarization, frequently mentioned in stories in which former President Donald Trump is cast as the nation’s sole polarizer.

Here is a sentence drawn at random from a recent Courant opinion piece, JFK’s ‘Best and Brightest’ revisited,” written by Scott Badler, a former Harvard and Emerson writing instructor: “The nation is polarized, and it is rare that someone from one party votes with the other party.”

“Polarized” is the perfect word to describe a left-right standoff on irreconcilable issues. Think of Alaska’s frozen tundra, of lungs scorched by below zero temperatures, of breathless politicians swooning into man-high snow drifts.

Bader supposes that the John F. Kennedy era was considerably more bipartisan and well-mannered than our own. JFK’s influencers were a less coarse, more agreeable lot. Then too, Kennedy surrounded himself with “the best and brightest – skilled, accomplished, intelligent and quick thinking. They were political intellectuals, corporate leaders and public officials… We need a new breed of the best and brightest to make politics welcoming again.”

The age of Lincoln was polarized. His cabinet was a rare assembly of the best and brightest of the day, some members having once been political opponents. Lincoln’s rhetoric as a leading representative of a new Republican Party, and later as President of a “House Divided” on the question of slavery, was effective, stunningly apposite, and on occasion politely humorous.

This is what Lincoln said at the close of the Illinois Republican State Convention in June 1858: “If we could first know where [emphasis Lincoln’s] we are, and whither we are tending, we could better judge what to do, and how to do it. We are now far into the fifth year, since a policy was initiated, with the avowed object, and confident promise, of putting an end to slavery agitation. Under the operation of that policy, that agitation has not only, not ceased, but has constantly augmented. In my opinion, it will not cease, until a crisis shall have been reached, and passed – ‘A house divided against itself cannot stand.’ I believe this government cannot endure permanently half slave and half free. I do not expect the Union to be dissolved - I do not expect the house to fall - but I do expect it will cease to be divided. It will become all one thing, or all the other.”

But the nation was divided, the union was dissolved. It did fall into warring factions and, in the end, following a bloody Civil War, it ceased to be divided. It became, with the military defeat of the slave power, all one thing. And the nation’s graveyards, north and south, still bare silent witness to a fatal division on points of profit and honor.

Today, Democrats, including President Joe Biden, incautiously call some Republicans -- and by extension all Republicans -- “fascists,” without quite understanding that the fascist state, historically, is the totalitarian command state against which Republicans have been inveighing since President Ronald Reagan warned, “Concentrated power has always been the enemy of liberty.”

Today, the Republican Party that effectively ended the slave power in the Re-United States, is routinely cursed as “racist” by political alchemists. That garbage should instantly be deposited in garbage bins. Much of our postmodern feverish hyperbole is the inevitable consequence of bad manners, about which Bill Buckley warned, “The trouble with bad manners is that they sometimes lead to murder.”

The roots in the words “police”, “political “and “policy” are interconnected -- from the Greek polis, "city". And politeness is the gleaming polish of the civilized city – from the Latin civilis, "relating to a citizen, relating to public life, befitting a citizen, popular, affable, courteous (emphasis mine)."

Badler is right. In moving from John Kennedy to Joe Biden, we have become less civil, and therefore less civilized. To put it another way, the cultural barbarians have triumphed. Courtesy is no longer popular -- from the Latin popularis, "belonging to the people, general, common, devoted to or accepted by the people, democratic," from populus "people".

Here in Connecticut, majority Democrats need not struggle with polarization, which usually occurs when political power is more or less evenly distributed between political factions. There is very little polarization in totalitarian countries such as Korea or China.

Because of their superior numbers in the General Assembly, it has been very easy for Democrats to marginalize Republicans through party leaders that strangle reasonable opposing ideas in their cribs. The Republican Party hardly exists at in Connecticut’s crumbling Democrat cities. And this election season Governor Ned Lamont -- who for two years has exerted, with winks from the Democrat super-majority in the General Assembly, plenary powers that might have made the last colonial governor of Connecticut blush with shame -- has allowed only two debates between himself and Republican Party opponent Bob Stefanowski.

Lincoln and Douglas held seven debates, averaging about two hours in length, strategically located at equidistant points covering the whole of Illinois. And though newspapers of the day were little more than party organs, the Lincoln-Douglas media published accurate stenographic reports of the debates, not merely attenuated accounts of the confrontations spiced with polarizing reportorial biases.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Lamont And Angelic Governance

John Droney “If men were angels,” said James Madison, “no government would be necessary.” And if governors were angels, no political advisors such as John Droney, former state Democrat Party chairman and Lamont supporter, would be necessary Droney along with other angels and academics, are now offering their expertise, which is considerable, to Governor Ned Lamont, battered for the last couple of weeks for having been too opaque concerning the wicked Machiavellian way of professional politicians. Somewhat like former President Donald Trump, Lamont is not a professional politician; he is a millionaire who lives in toney Greenwich, along with other millionaires such as U.S. Senator Dick Blumenthal. He makes lots of money – Greenwich is a rather high priced burg – but less than his enterprising wife, Annie Lamont. Droney is caught spilling the political beans in a Courant piece titled “ As Gov. Lamont faces questions on Annie Lamont’s investments and state contracts, critics say m

Connecticut Down, Part 1

The Cynic The Cynic And The City Mouse At The Oracle The Oracle is owned by a hedge fund manager in lower Connecticut. The restaurant opened briefly when Coronavirus first started breathing on its windows and, as quickly, was shuttered by order of the honorable Governor Ned Lamont, along with many other restaurants in Connecticut, including the two diners most frequented by The Cynic for breakfast. The reader, if he is attentive to the post-modern snake pit, may have noticed that Americans, as a general rule, are a tolerant people. They are disarmingly tolerant of revolutionary minded politicians; how else to account for the popularity and frequent press notice of a radical political zephyr such as New York U.S. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez? However tolerant Americans may be of politicians given to revolutionary experimentation, they guard jealously their own personal prerogatives. The Cynic greatly resented the facemask he had been forced to wear for a full year, regar

Blumenthal the Hare

Blumenthal, Biden In the campaign season now upon us, money is, more than ever, the mother’s milk of politics. U.S. Senator Dick Blumenthal, we all know, is rich in every sense of the word. He is a multi-millionaire who lives in splendor in Greenwich, Connecticut, a billionaire’s Eden. And he, as well as other Democrat U.S. Congresspersons, also redundantly rich – such as 3 rd District U.S. Representatives Rosa DeLauro, first elected to the U.S. House of Representatives more than three decades ago in 1990, and 4 th District U.S. Representative Jim Himes, now enjoying his seventh term in office – is able at the drop of a hat to assemble a formidable campaign war chest that will serve to discourage primary opponents and assure an effortless glide path to victory. In addition to personal wealth, Blumenthal is also rich in mostly flattering news reports, many of which he or his staff had a hand in creating through carefully crafted news releases not always critically examined by Conn