Skip to main content

The Virtue of Cynicism


My neighbor, who has grown comfortable with cynicism, tells me that people think they own property, but in fact property owns people, and nowhere is this truer than in Connecticut. Ownership is inseparable from the power to dispose of property or assets. If you can’t renovate or sell your property, you don’t own it. The power inherent in property ownership in Connecticut is cripplingly hedged about with ever increasing tax obligations and regulations.

 

Municipal governments in Connecticut rely on property taxes to finance operations, school construction and maintenance for instance. People like town government because municipal government is more responsive to “the voice of the people” as expressed in Town Halls across the state. Town Hall representation is the closest this country has come to true democracy, an ancient form of government in which the people directly decide the course of political action. In ancient Greece, the demos, from which we derive our notion of “democracy,” was the principal law and policy making body.

 

The front page, top of the fold headline in this morning’s Hartford Courant reads: ¨Towns eyeing tax relief,” news that should come as a relief to hard pressed middleclass working taxpayers crushed, Democrats have told us in the recently concluded midterm elections, by an oppressive “affordability crisis.”

 

Here is the lede to the story: “As many Connecticut homeowners balk at soaring assessments with rising tax bills, Stratford has become the latest town to put through a residential tax relief measure...” However, “Whatever revenue is lost from one-family homes will likely be made up by higher taxes on businesses and multifamily properties.” This is not tax relief but rather a shifting of the tax burden from one tax carrier to another. True tax relief would require a true tax cut across the board, the cut to be back filled by governmental spending relief. But spending cuts are as rare in Connecticut as straightforward politicians. Why so? Because a real solution to the problem of unaffordability – tax and spending cuts – is regarded by state and national politicians as a capital offense to the dignity of upright politicians whose business it is to help their constituents with the problem of affordability, caused in large part by helpful politicians.

 

My cynical neighbor believes that property owns people for several reasons. Taxing on housing, he grouses, always goes up in defiance of the general rule – what goes up must come down. He paid his ownership tax when he first purchased his house thirty years ago. And although he paid a purchase tax on his lawn mower only once when he bought it, he pays the tax on his house every reporting year. And although the house has grown older as he has, thus incurring maintenance expenses over the years, taxes on his house continue to rise according to Connecticut’s mill rate formula -- Property tax = Assessed value × Mill rate ÷ 1,000. Retired, his income is stationary, but his taxes and expenses, defying the laws of gravity, always go up and never come down.

 

Now then, there are three ways to increase affordability: 1) Taxes might be reduced. This would leave important monetary assets in the pockets of middle class workers. 2) Tax income might be enlarged by means of a reduction in very costly governmental regulations that affect businesses. 3) Connecticut’s progressive government might increase taxes for groups of people whose great wealth insulates them, so it is supposed, from the predations of tax hungry progressive politicians.

 

There are important unconfronted difficulties with number 3).  Millionaires and billionaires are fleet-footed and may easily escape asset reduction. Then too, the ever increasing gap between spending – i.e. the cost of governmental interference on what used to be called “the free market” -- and tax collection cannot be backfilled by plundering millionaires and billionaires. The ungovernable itch to spend can only be reduced through spending reductions. True believing socialists like Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders are not prepared to throw overboard the usual socialist bromides that have kept them in power for, in Sanders’ case, four decades. The recent midterm elections have taught us that unworkable progressive projects may yet work to generate votes for pious socialists.

 

The only effective solution to fleeing millionaires in a free market system is to dispense with both the free market and the millionaires: Get thee to a Gulag! That solution is implicit in the ruminations of Sanders and the Democratic Socialists of America’s Stalinist manifesto.

 

The Tax Foundation tells us: “Among federal taxes, the highest earners pay the largest share by a wide margin: the top 1% of filers paid 40.4% of all federal individual income taxes in 2022, and the top 10% paid 72%. Who pays the most taxes by income level depends on which tax you look at, though. Income, capital gains, and estate taxes concentrate heavily at the top; payroll taxes fall proportionally harder on wage earners below the Social Security wage cap; and excise taxes take a bigger bite, as a share of income, from lower-income households.”

 

Millionaires, my neighborhood cynic tells me, we shall always have with us under a free market system – as well as the poor. Under a free market system, Abraham Lincoln tells us, the poor are unchained from class poverty. But there is no reason why he, a cynical middle class taxpayer now retired, should be burdened with taxes that defy the laws of gravity, not to mention common sense.


“Nothing is so uncommon as common sense,” G. K. Chesterton tells us. As proof of the theorem, my enlightened cynic points to our unenlightened tax system. He prefers a flat or fair tax, and non-repetitive property taxes recovered by cuts in spending.

 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Blumenthal Burisma Connection

Steve Hilton , a Fox News commentator who over the weekend had connected some Burisma corruption dots, had this to say about Connecticut U.S. Senator Dick Blumenthal’s association with the tangled knot of corruption in Ukraine: “We cross-referenced the Senate co-sponsors of Ed Markey's Ukraine gas bill with the list of Democrats whom Burisma lobbyist, David Leiter, routinely gave money to and found another one -- one of the most sanctimonious of them all, actually -- Sen. Richard Blumenthal."

PCBs, GOOD FOR YOUR HEALTH

By Gerald and Natalie Sirkin c2007 A front-page story on PCBs in the March 9 News-Times is just wrong. The first thing to know about PCBs is that they never killed a single person nor did they ever cause cancer. The second is that although they are invariably called “cancer-causing,” that designation comes chiefly from a single rat study. The third thing is that the subject rats were exposed daily for 21 months to 100 parts per million (ppm) of PCBs containing 60% chlorine. (The 100 ppm was about 5,000 times the tolerable daily intake of PCBs set by FDA in 1973.) When rats were exposed to PCBs containing less chlorine, they developed no cancers. The fourth, that when the exposed rats were allowed to live out their lives, they had fewer cancers and lived longer than the unexposed rats. PCBs is a family of chemicals known as polychlorinated biphenyls. PCBs contain chlorine ranging from 12% to 70%. They were used in two General Electric plants that manufactured electrical equipmen...

Taking The Fifth, After Esty

Whether or not U.S. Representative Elizabeth Esty will serve the remainder of her term or resign immediately is very much an open question. But, in any case, the battle for Connecticut’s 5 th U.S. Congressional District has begun with a show of unexpected fireworks. For many years, the 5 th District was a toss-up proposition; both Republicans and Democrats have held and surrendered the seat. Geographically the 5 th District touches the border of New York from Connecticut’s northern-most point to Danbury in the southern quadrant and includes much of Litchfield county and parts of Fairfield, Hartford and New Haven counties. Party affiliation is competitive, in round figures, 30 percent Democrat, 25 percent Republican and 45 percent unaffiliated. Over the years, the Democrat Party in Connecticut has moved from the center to the left, but the 5 th District has been a moderate preserve. During the Obama presidential election, Republican moderates within Connecticut's U.S. ...